How to choose a biometric attendance machine
Most buyers start with the machine and end with a spreadsheet problem. Start from the other end: where the punches have to go. These eight steps take about an hour and save a year of workarounds.
1. Start with your HR or payroll software
Attendance is only useful once it reaches the software that pays people or manages leave. Before looking at any terminal, write down where punches must end up: the HR system, the payroll software, the ERP, or a school system.
Then ask two questions of every terminal you consider. Does a ready-made integration exist between this terminal and my software? And does that integration send what my software expects: individual punches, or finished shifts? If the answer is no, you are signing up for monthly exports. The integrations by software pages show how this works for the most common systems.
2. Count the peak, not the headcount
A terminal's capacity (how many users it holds) matters less than its throughput at your busiest moment. Two hundred people arriving between 8:50 and 9:00 need either a fast face terminal or more than one terminal; two hundred people spread over three shifts may be fine with one.
- Count how many people arrive at each entrance in the busiest ten minutes.
- Check the user, template and log capacity, with room for two or three years of growth.
- Plan one terminal per entrance that people actually use, not one per building.
3. Choose how people identify themselves
| Your situation | Usually the best fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Office, stable team, modest budget | Fingerprint | Lowest cost, accurate for healthy fingers |
| Busy entrance, hygiene, worn or dirty hands | Face recognition | Touchless and fast on approach |
| Restricted rooms, no cameras wanted | Palm vein | Touchless and very hard to fake |
| Visitors, contractors, canteen, doors | RFID card | Cheap, fast, no biometric needed |
| Remote or moving sites, vehicles | GPS terminal | Location on every punch, works over 4G |
Whatever you choose, make sure the terminal offers a fallback (a card or a PIN) for the few people whose biometric never reads well. Otherwise they end up signing a paper register, which defeats the point.
4. Decide how the terminal connects
There are three ways a terminal hands over its punches, and they decide how much work the system creates later:
- Standalone: punches stay in the terminal until someone downloads them on a USB stick.
- Local network and a PC: software on an office PC pulls the punches. It works for one site, as long as the PC stays on.
- Cloud push: the terminal sends every punch over the internet as it happens, from any site, with no PC. It needs an internet connection (Wi-Fi, LAN or a SIM card) and keeps punches in memory when the connection drops.
For more than one site, or for an HR system in the cloud, cloud push is usually the only arrangement that does not need someone to babysit it.
5. Plan enrolment, changes and leavers
Every new joiner has to be enrolled, and every leaver removed, on every terminal they used. With two terminals that is a chore; with twenty across five sites it becomes a risk. Ask how a person is enrolled once and synced to all terminals, and how a leaver is removed everywhere in one step.
Fingerprint templates from different brands are often not interchangeable. If you plan to mix brands, expect people to enrol separately on each brand, or standardise on one family of terminals for each site.
6. Check your privacy obligations
Biometric data is personal data everywhere and sensitive data in many places. Before you install, find out whether you must give notice, ask for consent, offer an alternative such as a card, or carry out a risk assessment. Write a short notice for staff explaining what is stored and why. The privacy law guide covers India, the EU and UK, the US and the Gulf.
7. Compare the three-year cost, not the price tag
| Cost item | What to include |
|---|---|
| Terminals | Purchase price per terminal, plus spares |
| Installation | Mounting, power, network or SIM card, door wiring if used |
| Licences | Yearly fee per terminal or per user, if any |
| Integration | A ready-made integration, or a one-off project and its upkeep |
| PC or server | Hardware, backups and somebody to look after it |
| Staff time | Hours spent every month exporting, fixing and re-typing attendance |
The last line is the one most comparisons leave out, and over three years it is often the largest. A cheap terminal that needs a day of HR time every month is not cheap.
8. Ask for a demo with your own software
Before you buy, ask to see a punch arrive in your own HR or payroll system, not a demo account. Then test the cases that cause trouble later:
- your hardest users: worn fingers, masks, glasses, safety helmets;
- a night shift that crosses midnight;
- the network unplugged for ten minutes, then reconnected;
- a leaver removed: are they gone from every terminal?
The one-page checklist
- Which software must receive punches, and is there a ready-made integration?
- How many people arrive in the busiest ten minutes at each entrance?
- Which credential suits the site, and what is the fallback?
- How does the terminal connect, and what happens offline?
- How are joiners enrolled and leavers removed across all terminals?
- What notice, consent or alternative does the law require?
- What is the three-year cost, including staff time?
- Have I seen it work with my own software?
Talk it through with Cams
Cams makes fingerprint, face and card terminals and connects them, and 90+ other brands, to HR and payroll software. Send your software, sites and headcount for a suggested setup.